Romance deserves better.

On “Fairy Smut”
Over Halloween weekend, two newspapers covered midnight parties for the same Sarah J. Maas romantasy novel. In London, the Telegraph sent Lauren Shirreff to the Saucy Starlit Ball. One of the women she met there, Meighan Worsley, told her that reading Maas after the birth of her first child had helped her through postnatal depression. Two old friends, a lawyer and a teacher, told her they’d been reading romance together since their Cambridge days. The headline? "The middle-class women who can’t get enough of ‘fairy porn’."
What I keep coming back to is a detail in Shirreff’s own account. She says she enjoyed the book and was surprised to get about a hundred pages in before she even found a mention of sex. And what was this first mention? A man taking responsibility for contraception. Steady on, ladies.
Across the Atlantic, the New York Times covered the launch in Brooklyn. The headline: “They Can’t Get Enough of the ‘Queen of Fairy Smut’ (or Her Merch)".
Between them, the two headlines found room to tell us the readers’ social class, what else was for sale and, twice, what we were meant to find so funny. You had to read on to find out who wrote the book.
Maas has sold more than 100 million books worldwide. By the end of publication day on 27 October, pre-orders and sales of A Court of Splintered Harmony had reached 1.7 million English-language print and ebook copies across the US, Canada, the UK and Australia. It’s the sixth book in her A Court of Thorns and Roses series. The seventh, A Court of Forgotten Melody, is due on 12 January 2027.
And yet, and yet, the word both papers agreed on was “fairy”. It isn’t even how she spells it.
Start with the spelling
Maas writes about the Fae. The word she uses is faerie. It’s not a made-up word like Tolkien’s. It’s old English spelling. Spenser used it for The Faerie Queene in 1590.” And it’s right there in her publisher’s blurb for the first book. I know how seriously a Tolkien reader can take a single word, and as someone opening a bookshop in Oxford, I’m all for it. I’d just like to know why we’re expected to know what a hobbit is, while the vocabulary of a fantasy world built by a woman is fair game for a punchline?
To give credit where it’s due. National Geographic got faerie right."Faerie smut' is having a moment — just like it did in 1500'". In February 2025, Kelly Faircloth explained that some of Maas’s own readers use “faerie smut” affectionately. I still rolled my eyes at the headline, but I’m glad I read on.
Faircloth traces Maas’s Tamlin back to the Scottish ballad Tam Lin. On Halloween, Janet pulls the man she loves off his horse and holds on through every shape the fairies give him. She’s the one who gets him out. Sir Walter Scott published his own version of the ballad in 1802. I’d quite like to shelve Scott beside Maas at Lara’s and see which of them gets called smut.
The Hollywood test
Yes, there’s sex in these books. The Cut counted one detailed sex scene in the first book of the series. The later books have more. But please tell me, at what point am I supposed to stop caring what happens to these characters because they have sex every so often? There’s war, grief, sisterhood, trauma, court politics, found family and a woman slowly learning she’s allowed to want things. (I think most women can relate to that last one.)
Imagine a woman telling you she loved Oppenheimer and you giving her a knowing wink. “Oh, you went for the sex scenes, did you?” You’d sound like a prat. Say much the same thing to a woman who loved a romance novel, any romance novel, and somehow she’s the one who’s supposed to be embarrassed.
With cinema, we understand that a story can contain sex without being only about sex. Yet a woman writes one explicit page, or fifty, and suddenly the whole book is “smut”. Someone will even tell you it doesn’t count as “real reading”. When did you last hear someone come out of a romantic film and say, “Well, that doesn’t count as watching a film”?
It’s horror when he writes it
Stephen King has spent more than fifty years writing horrific things. We can talk about his work without reducing him to the worst thing that happens in his books.
George R. R. Martin writes about sex, including sexual violence. HBO gave us eight seasons of Game of Thrones and went back for spin-offs. GQ ran an entire piece under the headline “House of the Dragon’s Sex Scenes Aren’t Just About Sex”. I’d like to see Sarah J. Maas extended the same courtesy. Rebecca Yarros, too, the next time somebody calls her books “dragon smut”.
Go further back. People called D. H. Lawrence obscene, too. Penguin stood trial for publishing Lady Chatterley’s Lover. Yet we’ve managed to have quite a few conversations about that book since. I think it’s time women who write romance got some of those conversations, too.
Some might say it’s the love story people object to. Then what do we do with The English Patient? Michael Ondaatje put an affair at the heart of it. The novel shared the Booker Prize. The film won nine Oscars.
My favourite example is Gabriel García Márquez. In Love in the Time of Cholera, Florentino Ariza has 622 affairs while he waits for Fermina Daza. That one became a film, too. The New York Times Book Review said the novel may be “one of the greatest love stories ever told”. Now imagine it’s Fermina who has those 622 affairs, and the name on the cover belongs to a woman. What do you suppose the headline would be?
I wish I could say the sneering comes only from men. On 1 November, Melanie McDonagh wrote in The Spectator Australia that the popularity of Maas among women made her “question the wisdom of universal suffrage”. I knew we were supposed to defend our taste in books. I hadn’t realised we had to defend our right to vote as well.
What’s actually going on
As a romance author, I can write exactly what a woman wants in bed and publish that book myself. No man has to sign off on that scene. A woman can buy it with her own money, read it and decide for herself whether she’d like some of what the heroine is having.
Pointy ears, a shapeshifting cowboy, a billionaire boss. Take your pick. If the fantasy they have in common is a man who washes and knows where the clitoris is, I do wonder why anyone finds that so threatening.
What Maas actually said
In March, Maas sat down with Alex Cooper on Call Her Daddy and was asked, more or less, how it feels to be called a smut author. Her answer was the best thing I’ve heard on the subject.
She said she’s proud of her steamy scenes and quite happy to use the word herself. What makes her angry is the dismissal that comes with it, the idea that a few pages of sex cheapen everything around them. She and her readers have a giggle about the hot scenes, yes. Then a woman tells her she left an abusive husband after reading A Court of Mist and Fury, and the two of them stand there in tears.
Why I’m opening a romance bookshop
I’m taking my time with the renovations at Lara’s Bookshop on North Parade in Oxford. I want good lighting, shelves of hardbacks and limited editions, a glass of wine when the book club meets in the evening. A place where no one says “smut” or “romance” with a smirk.
I want to put an early romance paperback in a glass case and have somebody come in and say, “My mum had that one.” I want to hear which bit she still remembers forty years later, and I doubt it will be the sex scene.
I write dark romance myself. I know exactly how it feels to have years’ worth of work reduced to a few pages of explicit sex. I’m tired of people thinking anything written by a woman with even one page of explicit sex is porn. And most of all, I’m tired of the assumption that if women love something, it cannot be worth much.
Sources
The Telegraph report from the London ball, via AOL · The New York Times report from Brooklyn · The Times headline as listed on the reporter’s profile · Melanie McDonagh’s column in The Spectator Australia
The Guardian on Maas’s sales · Bloomsbury’s series guide and release dates · Bloomsbury’s blurb for the first book · Spenser’s 1590 edition of The Faerie Queene
The Cut on the sex scenes in ACOTAR · GQ on House of the Dragon · Penguin on the Lady Chatterley trial · The Booker Prizes on The English Patient · Vintage on Love in the Time of Cholera · Sarah J. Maas on Call Her Daddy
Comments