Apparently, Oxford’s New Romance Bookshop Is Too Dangerous for Instagram
Updated: Nov 6

Instagram has permanently banned Lara’s before it has even opened its doors. My hypothesis? My posts about Doctor Zhivago labelled me and my bookshop a “dangerous individual and organization.”
Lara’s is a romance bookshop on North Parade in Oxford. It’s set to open in summer 2027. At the moment it’s a building site: there are books to be bought, builders to organise, and a damp basement that will, with luck and a great deal of tanking, become hot desks by day and the book club room by night.
And now the to-do list also includes finding out why Instagram considers Lara’s a danger to the public.
Why this is such a big problem
Every indie bookshop is on Instagram. It’s where readers find bookshops, where bookshops find each other, and where most of the traffic comes from. Not having an account is a handicap.
But it's worse than that. When I added “Lara’s Bookshop Oxford” to the display name of my seven-year-old author account, without posting a single thing, Instagram suspended it within minutes under the same “dangerous individuals and organizations” policy.
Meta hasn't explained why. So how am I supposed to know whether another author, reader or bookshop who tags or mentions Lara’s might put their own account at risk? I don't know whether that would happen.
And that's my big concern. How can I reassure anyone else when simply putting my own bookshop's name in my own profile was followed by an immediate suspension?
When the problems began
On 9 October, Instagram suspended the shop’s account, @larasromancebookshop, under its policy on “dangerous individuals and organizations”. The suspension email arrived at 8:58 in the morning. At 11:46, a second email said the account had been reviewed and permanently disabled.
Two hours and forty-eight minutes.
Neither email named a post, a sentence, a photograph or an action.
What the "dangerous" bookshop had posted before suspension
Three posts were made, two text carousels and a video. That was the entire account.
The first carousel explained the shop’s name. My middle name comes from Lara in Doctor Zhivago, and the slides told the story of the novel: banned in the Soviet Union, smuggled to Italy to be published, and awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1958 — which Boris Pasternak was pressured into refusing. The final slide read: “Because sometimes a book is that dangerous.”
The second carousel introduced me as the owner: my name, my photograph, a short biography.
The last was a video of me walking through the empty shop on the day I collected the keys.
My Facebook pages are unaffected
All three posts are still up on Lara’s Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/larasoxford
Between them, these posts contain the words a bot may have picked up:
“revolution”
“Soviet Union”
“secretly printed”
“dangerous”
because I was describing Doctor Zhivago (!) and arguing that romance deserves to be taken seriously as a genre. (I did not mention the word feminism, but I did ask for romance, predominantly written and read by women, to be taken seriously.)
I can’t say those words caused the ban, because Meta has not told me what caused it. They simply closed my account.
Then my author account went too
Having lost the shop’s account, I decided to share the shop’s progress through my own Instagram account, @kelly_curtis_author, which I have used for seven years under my own name and my own face.
I assumed the Instagram bots had closed the bookshop’s account by accident because of the words I’d used to describe Doctor Zhivago, and I reckoned that as long as I didn’t use those particular words again, I should be fine. Because how could a romance bookshop be “dangerous individuals and organizations”?
On 29 October, I changed only my display name to include “Lara’s Bookshop Oxford”. The end result: “Kelly Curtis Lara’s Bookshop Oxford”. The username stayed the same. I posted nothing.
Within minutes, it was suspended under the same policy, “dangerous individuals and organizations”.
I appealed the suspension of my seven-year-old author account, @kelly_curtis_author, on 29 October, using Instagram's own appeal process on my phone. I completed the requested verification steps. I have screenshots documenting my appeal, along with the suspension and verification emails Meta sent me.
Instagram told me the review would usually take just over a day.
As of 3 November, five days later, I have received no decision. No email, no notification, no explanation. Nothing.
And now I cannot even log in, reset my password or return to the appeal screen to check what has happened. I have no way of knowing whether my account is still suspended, permanently disabled or something else entirely.
I have already done what Instagram asked me to do. It is Meta that has failed to tell me the outcome.
From my side, my seven-year-old account has effectively vanished.

Instagram’s last email to me was on 29 October: the suspension notice and a verification code. Since then, nothing. Not a decision, not a holding message, not a request for more information.

Here are some screenshots of the whole event
9 October, 8:58am: the bookshop account is suspended.
9 October, 11:46am: permanently disabled after “review”. Then 29 October, 1:22pm: the author account goes the same way.
29 October: the author account suspended, identity check submitted, appeal lodged. Instagram says it “usually takes just over a day”.


What Meta has from me
Over the course of all this I have submitted two valid passports — I’m a dual US and UK citizen — and a valid driving licence, completed email and phone checks, and recorded the video they asked for, more than once. The only explanation Meta has ever given is an email suggesting that I’d “digitally altered” my passport. I hadn't. I submitted multiple photographs of my passport, taken live through their app on my phone, following their instructions — including ensuring all four corners were visible.
These are the same passports, photographed on the same phone, that HMRC accepts for my tax account, that my bank accepts for online identity checks, and that satisfied the solicitors’ anti-money-laundering checks when I bought the building a month earlier. My passports and phone are good enough for the taxman, the bank and the lawyers. But apparently they’re not good enough for Instagram, which suggested my passport might be forged.
Beyond that email, Meta Business Support produced neither an explanation nor a way forward. I am not verified and cannot become verified, because Meta has deemed my ID unacceptable. And I cannot verify as a company, because I am a sole trader and Meta’s business verification only accepts a Companies House registration number (CRN) — which sole traders don’t have.

What happens when you try to reach a human
I spent hours with the Meta chatbot. It confirmed that I should be able to register as a sole trader. But it could not connect me to anyone. At one point it told me to click a separate “I’m having trouble” link. The supposedly separate help link simply led me straight back to the same bot. As I told it: “You are the ‘I’m having trouble’ link.” Then it sent me round the loop again. It's like something out of Black Mirror.

My other social media pages have the same posts but are unaffected
My Facebook pages, run by the same company, are running smoothly. The same three posts are still up on Lara’s Facebook page.
As far as I can tell, no human at Meta has looked at my Instagram accounts, and it’s impossible for me to get one to. This is what’s so dangerous about big tech if you’re a small business. You describe a famous novel and suddenly you’re a “dangerous individual and organization”, without any recourse.
My bookshop already has a website, a street address, a verified Google listing, utility bills, tax records, and a LinkedIn profile naming me as its owner, Kelly Lara Curtis. It’s not difficult to find out what Lara’s is and why I might have been writing about one of the most famous love stories ever written. Yet Meta says it cannot verify my identity.
What I’ve asked from Meta
I sent Meta a formal data-protection complaint and a subject access request by email on 29 October, with a corrected copy on 30 October. Hard copies went by tracked post to Meta’s data protection officers in Dublin and Menlo Park on 3 November. Under UK GDPR, Meta has one month to respond — by the end of November. If it doesn’t, the next stop is the Information Commissioner’s Office.
I want to know what triggered each decision, whether the two accounts were wrongly linked, why my documents were rejected, and whether a human being has been involved at any point.
Mostly, I want someone to look at three posts about a bookshop and tell me which part is dangerous.

What happens next
I don’t expect a reply. So here is what happens if there isn’t one. By 30 November, Meta should have responded to my subject access request, unless it has a legitimate reason to extend the deadline and informs me accordingly. If I receive no response, or one that fails to address my data-protection rights, I will take the matter to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO).
The ICO cannot restore my Instagram accounts, nor can it guarantee that Meta will explain every aspect of its decisions. But it can examine whether Meta has complied with its obligations under data-protection law and take appropriate action if it hasn't.
I don't think that's an unreasonable thing to ask.
Even Meta's Oversight Board has raised concerns
On 4 June 2026, Meta’s independent Oversight Board published its first ever decision on a permanently disabled Instagram account. It upheld that particular ban, which involved serious threats of violence against a journalist. But it also found wider problems with how Meta disables accounts, unclear rules, inadequate explanations, and an appeals process that doesn’t work well.
It said platforms should have clear, consistent rules for permanent bans, and should give affected users information and a way to appeal.
That's exactly what I can't do.
I have already appealed and done everything Instagram asked. I can’t log in to my account, I can’t check my appeal, and I can’t see any decision. And here’s the most Kafkaesque part: I can’t take my case to the Oversight Board either. Its appeals process needs a final decision from Meta and an account I can log into. I have neither.
So I am left with a very simple question. How am I supposed to pursue an appeal I’ve already submitted, when Meta won’t tell me whether it has made a decision and I can’t log in to the system to find out?
One of the reasons I wanted to open a bricks-and-mortar bookshop was to get away from big tech. Yet, ironically, that seems impossible in the twenty-first century.
5 November update
Just after midday, Facebook locked me out of the personal account I’ve had for twenty years. The last thing I’d done was reply to someone asking for book recommendations in a romance book club. Within seconds I was locked out and wondering whether I’d ever see my friends or colleagues again, since almost all the book-related traffic takes place on Meta.
I keep coming back to one detail. My personal Facebook profile lists me as “Author and Bookshop Owner” at “Lara’s Romance Bookshop Oxford”, with a start date of 6 October. There’s even a little padlock beside it. Three days after that date, Instagram disabled the bookshop’s account. On 29 October, it suspended my author account minutes after I added the bookshop to my display name only. So when Facebook locked me out today, my first thought was, has listing my own bookshop as my workplace somehow flagged this account too? I asked Meta whether the incidents were connected.
They could not tell me.
I got my personal Facebook account back after a video selfie and thankfully getting through to someone human for the first time, but that person could not help me with anything other than my personal Facebook page. After being reactivated, I discovered I had to also manually reactivate the bookshop’s Facebook Page. Both are back now. I’m relieved, but I’d still quite like to know how opening a bookshop got me to the point where I’m second-guessing what to put under Works at.


Later on 5 November — What do I do now?
Four hours later, it happened again. The same thing triggered it. Someone in a book club group asked for sci-fi and fantasy recommendations. I gave her Dungeon Crawler Carl. The woman who asked put a heart on my answer and then I was locked out again and being asked to prove I was human. I sent Facebook another video of my face and spent another hour trying to get my account back. This time I asked for a human and was refused.
“Account integrity” again according to the bot when I asked what I’d actually done. “I’m not able to share more about how that decision was made,” the chatbot told me. By 5.18 pm, Facebook had reviewed my account and decided that it does follow its rules.
So what, exactly, am I supposed to do differently tomorrow?
And there was Lara’s Oxford again, on the list of deactivated Pages. I’d clicked “Reactivate” the first time. This time I hesitated for the evening — I couldn’t quite grasp that my bookshop was causing so much trouble — and then turned it back on, because not being findable on Meta is a severe handicap for anything in the bookish world. The Page is live. I won’t be posting on it until this is resolved.
And of course I want to know whether having Lara’s Bookshop attached to my name has anything to do with this. Meta hasn’t answered that question. Meanwhile, every time I lose my personal Facebook account, I also lose my author Pages. Those are the pages I’ve spent years building, where I tell my readers when the next book is coming out. Those books pay my bills. I can’t afford to press that button again just to see what happens.
What makes this even more Kafkaesque: my author Pages — some of them verified by Meta — are all under pen names I made up. It’s the bricks-and-mortar bookshop under my own name that’s causing all the problems. Ironically, a very twenty-first-century problem.
So what do I do now? For Lara’s, I’m sticking to TikTok. I may try Bluesky. I’ll keep writing here, and you can sign up for the mailing list to hear how the shop is coming along.
I’m opening a bookshop on North Parade. I’d like to be able to recommend a book without wondering whether I’ll still have an account five seconds later.

6 November
Is something caught in a loop? The warning that I cannot run ads is still sitting in my notifications — twice over, one for each of yesterday’s lockouts. I have not run an advert in six months, if not longer. When I did, I ran them for years under my pen names, from this same personal account. Meta has my tax number, my payment card, my ID. All of it is attached to the personal Facebook account it keeps trying to suspend.
I’m not touching anything for now, because every time I do something I’m suspended for “account integrity” — though doing nothing hasn’t protected me either; the last two lockouts came from recommending books. It’s a no-win situation, and I am so tired of talking to Meta’s bots, which cannot give me any information.

The log
9 October — Bookshop account suspended, 8:58am. Permanently disabled, 11:46am. Passport rejected, 6:14pm.
29 October — Author account suspended minutes after a display-name change. Appeal lodged. Complaint and subject access request emailed to Meta.
30 October — Corrected complaint emailed.
2 November — Cannot log in. Password reset fails.
3 November — Hard copies posted, tracked, to Dublin and Menlo Park. No word from Instagram since 29 October.
5 November, midday — Locked out of my personal Facebook account after a comment in a book group. Cleared by human review within the hour. All author pages including pen names came back. Lara’s Oxford was deactivated; I turned it on.
5 November, evening — Locked out of my personal Facebook account a second time after a comment in a book group. Cleared by automated review the same evening in a little over an hour. All author pages including pen names came back. Lara’s Oxford was deactivated again; I turned it back on but will not be posting or updating anything on Facebook until this is resolved.
6 November, lunchtime — I logged in only to check the shop’s Page was still there. Waiting in the notifications: two “URGENT” advertising restrictions, both from yesterday — from an account that hasn’t run an advert in six months.
30 November — Expected deadline for Meta's response to my subject access request, unless lawfully extended.
In the meantime
Lara’s is still happening. You can follow my progress at larasoxford.com, where you can also sign up for the newsletter — a few book recommendations each month and news of the shop — and on TikTok. There will be books, hot desks, book clubs, coffee, tea, wine, and a place in Oxford for people who take love stories seriously.




Comments